Professor Criticizes Plan to Replace Sin Tax with General Budget
The user wants a short summary (1-2 sentences, 120-220 chars, max 240) for a news deck. Must be in English only. No filler, no quotes, no markdown. Just the summary text. Key points: Professor Burachit Singkaneti (NIDA) criticizes governmen
Professor Burachit Singkaneti from NIDA’s Faculty of Law said the government’s proposal to scrap the 2% sin tax and replace it with general budget allocations is a deceitful move that cannot be implemented. He argued it would mainly benefit alcohol and tobacco businesses, while insisting the earmarked tax system is reasonable and fully compliant with fiscal discipline laws. He added that the draft law would cut articles 11‑14 of the existing legislation, making any ministerial rule to collect replacement taxes impossible. Former Deputy Health Minister Dr. Somkid Chunasorasri warned that abolishing the sin tax would undermine disease prevention, raise non‑communicable illness rates, increase the state’s health‑care burden, and slash public‑health budgets, worsening hospital deficits. He stressed that the earmarked tax is already subject to three layers of oversight—internal checks, the State Audit Office, and a revolving fund committee—so there is no fiscal‑discipline problem and no need to amend the law.